@vidurchhabra

Thanks for sharing your valued viewpoint. Our posts crossed.

Please stay true to that spirit, and respond further why Company Q&A Section - is not the best place for idea generation exercises mentioned.

Perhaps some new members are not aware of the utility and purpose of the different sections. But VP old-timers certainly are.

Stock Opportunity is serious business. No slack allowed here.
Company Q&A - is free-format. Use as light or as heavy information/base analysis as you want.

Moderation is a double-edged sword.

I guess what the Admin team is saying is that the interests of the naive investor need to be protected, lest he/she stop investing after a bitter investing experience upfront, in spite of following some thread on VP.

What Subash is saying is that the naive investor needs to grow up, and cannot be spoonfed/handheld.
We all know that he started this thread to tell us which side of the sword he thinks is sharper.

This is a classic problem in mentoring (not only investing).
Someone needs to draw a line somewhere as the Admin team (metnors) did.
Lets all agree to disagree and get back to presenting our views in a constructive manner on where the line needs to be drawn.

Hi Sir,

Is Rama Phosphates, a nanocap, also forming a cup handle pattern (Nov 5, 2014 to Nov 2, 2015 for the cup and rest handle)? Though volumes are required for the confirmation of breakout at the end of the handle.

Rama Phosphates is manufacturing SSP fertilizers and sulphuric acid.

Regards
Sri Krishna Bhutra

bijoy,

The problem to admin getting lax and allowing the kind of posts to discuss new stocks is that there will be a lot of low quality discussions on junk kind of stocks and at some point of time when the music stops in these counters first time naive investors who are lured by crazy price movements in illiquid counters would be burnt badly and would never come back to the stock markets.

The aim of VP remember is to educate the investors and make them better investors.

In TED there was lockout of accounts without giving any reason and without giving any chance to answer . Here it is not so and subash can put up any grievance he wants to.

I think subash nayak should take this thing in his stride and move on and start posting again whenever wherever he feels value is being added. I have always admired his investment acumen and would urge him to continue posting without any ill feelings. Just consider this as a small reprimand from a school called VP.

There will be points and arguments against the objections raised against his post but at the end of the day its no use arguing endlessly and always better to move on with a fresh start.