Comparison of well-known stock advisory services

****'S past performance was very good , but somehow last one year performance is bad. His stocks going in time correction.he has genuine effort to help investors and easily reachable to discuss. He has dedicated section where u can ask him any question on stocks.

 

Let's share each advisories recommendation in a whatsapp group. I have subscription of 2 advisories. We can save huge subscription cost by sharing each others. Mail me nirajsinghla@gmail.com

 

Any latest returns comparison of adversaries?

 

Only one advisory gives annual returns. no point comparing them.

Me and my friend had all advisory at some point. Only Prudent Equity, Equity Master and Katalyst can be taken seriously. rest are average.

 

raj boss....don't agree wd u. equitymaster is very bad. too many subscibers....too many schemes. katalyst is also average....one stock do well.....5 under perform.

 

So that leaves prudent equity as undisputed leader ?! Have not heard any negative comments about their recos in this forum.. or is it just that disgruntled members of PE are not in this forum??

Btw Any feedback on "value investing India report"?

 

Charli - Did you subscribe to PE? I'm also looking for a stock advisory services and from the thread, thinking of joining Prudent Equity. Any dissatisfied member of PE in the forum?

 

Not yet. Please follow the other thread on "Prudent Equity"... I have few open questions and once i get some answers, i will decide. For now, i have not seen any negatives about PE in this forum. Looks like PE is way to go going by their past track record.

 

@s prasad or @Charli, did u join ?

By the way, Are there any WhatsApp group based investor groups discussing on investment opportunities? Pls dm me. I would like to be part of such groups.

 

https://operatorfii.wordpress.com

Hi all. Any reviews of the above investment advisor? Charges are on the higher side, which is not always a benchmark.

 

who is this? The name is hidden in your message? What do they charge?

 

No longer offering service based on their website due to sebi rules on investment advisor regn.

 

Went to their website. Looks like they started their countdown (they call lockdown) to membership closure, as mentioned by some boarders in another pe thread. Looks interesting and if closed, first of its kind.. perplexing why anyone would want not to milk the cow??

 

prdnt eqt stocks are not performing now a days . when market goes sidelines , real test is to be made .a bad recommendations and panic to sell the stock might mar the profits in couple of stocks . Stock markets are really nasty place for commoners , as one will get 20 percent compound interest over long run if one invests in mutual fund for long .

 

Any body subscribed to Finapple ideas led by Sandip Sabharwal. Recently started in late 2014. Performance on their website is pretty good. However want to know the honest feedback.

Thanks
Mohit

 

I think mostly he may be doing trading ideas. Very few subscribers may be there.

 

This problem is that with recos of all advisories I think. Takes time for stock to give gains. You have to see if Co fundamentals are OK and EPS is growing. Stock price is not relevant as will follow EPS in future.

 

they are free to change their providing suitable execuses . the lockdown is a markeing gimmick .

 

@Honeybee - I have not yet joined PE

@Charli - Did you join PE? any feedback?

 

Isn't it shocking that Finappple is posting such phenomenal performance on its website but there is no one in this forum to give their honest feedback ?