Saral Gyan stock advisory

Shibi · Aug 26, 2016

Sonia said: ↑

Although stocks are meant to be held for 12-24months, but my argument is that how can they recommend a stock without any Margin of safety? How different would they be from a novice investor? They have no right to call themselves as stock advisory, it's a SHAME.
Click to expand...

If you had invested in all stocks recommended by Saral Gyan as per your chart (say investing the same value for each stock at the recommended price), the investment would have appreciated 21.85%, with an average holding period of 6 months. How is 21.85% in 6 months (not annualized) bad?

Shrikant bapat · Sep 2, 2016

Sonia said: ↑

Thank you all for your feedback. I had subscribed with Saral Gyan last year for the combo package i.e. Value picks, stock recommendation and 15% @90days.

I am strongly (-) NEGATIVE on them and advice all to stay away, especially common investors who value their hard earned money.

Why am I (-) NEGATIVE? Below is the performance of their stocks recommended. The performance looks much better today, but if u had seen them in Jan 2016 it was horrible and Feb2016 was like Red alert. If you like playing darts or trying your chance in a lottery, you may subscribe with them.

Although stocks are meant to be held for 12-24months, but my argument is that how can they recommend a stock without any Margin of safety? How different would they be from a novice investor? They have no right to call themselves as stock advisory, it's a SHAME.

I strongly believe a stock advisory should have expertise in recommending stock with good margin of safety and should be honest and committed to their subscribers.

I hereby close this thread at my end.

View attachment 501
I am planning to subscribe for wealth builder @ 15000/- per year for saral gyan.
please let me know about it because they claim that their recommendations have given 250% return since jan 1 , 2013, against sensex or nifty return of 43%.

@kharb @Srouta Mukherjee @RAMA MURTHY SASTRY CHALLA @SUNNY @Livermore @Mani @Sachin pathak @Long Term @uppu.narayan @bhaskarbora67 @Occasional_visitor @frontier @Abhisavengrow @w4wealth @Shrikant bapat @rockstar1982 @davis ittoop @Alok Rathod
Click to expand...

Manish Kumar · Sep 16, 2016

Sonia said: ↑

Thank you all for your feedback. I had subscribed with Saral Gyan last year for the combo package i.e. Value picks, stock recommendation and 15% @90days.

I am strongly (-) NEGATIVE on them and advice all to stay away, especially common investors who value their hard earned money.

Why am I (-) NEGATIVE? Below is the performance of their stocks recommended. The performance looks much better today, but if u had seen them in Jan 2016 it was horrible and Feb2016 was like Red alert. If you like playing darts or trying your chance in a lottery, you may subscribe with them.

Although stocks are meant to be held for 12-24months, but my argument is that how can they recommend a stock without any Margin of safety? How different would they be from a novice investor? They have no right to call themselves as stock advisory, it's a SHAME.

I strongly believe a stock advisory should have expertise in recommending stock with good margin of safety and should be honest and committed to their subscribers.

[/USER]
Click to expand...

@ Sonia, How does the chart stand now ?
Are you in profits ?
Can you please upload a recent standings of your investments.
Planning to subscribe to SG's Hidden Gems ...

sachin123 · Dec 25, 2016

Sonia said: ↑

Thank you all for your feedback. I had subscribed with Saral Gyan last year for the combo package i.e. Value picks, stock recommendation and 15% @90days.

I am strongly (-) NEGATIVE on them and advice all to stay away, especially common investors who value their hard earned money.

Why am I (-) NEGATIVE? Below is the performance of their stocks recommended. The performance looks much better today, but if u had seen them in Jan 2016 it was horrible and Feb2016 was like Red alert. If you like playing darts or trying your chance in a lottery, you may subscribe with them.

Although stocks are meant to be held for 12-24months, but my argument is that how can they recommend a stock without any Margin of safety? How different would they be from a novice investor? They have no right to call themselves as stock advisory, it's a SHAME.

I strongly believe a stock advisory should have expertise in recommending stock with good margin of safety and should be honest and committed to their subscribers.

I hereby close this thread at my end.

View attachment 501

@kharb @Srouta Mukherjee @RAMA MURTHY SASTRY CHALLA @SUNNY @Livermore @Mani @Sachin pathak @Long Term @uppu.narayan @bhaskarbora67 @Occasional_visitor @frontier @Abhisavengrow @w4wealth @Shrikant bapat @rockstar1982 @davis ittoop @Alok Rathod
Click to expand...

hello as ur tracksheet shows the stockes r of good quality and some has given 100 percent appericiation so how can v know who is better without seeing others tracksheet

sachin123 · Dec 25, 2016

the stock u wrote avanti feed is shown rs 30 in tracksheet,,,other r also at very low rate ur described rate is high mr bhaskar

Vijaykh · Dec 26, 2017

Sonia said: ↑

Dear All,

Please share your experience if you have subscribed to any services of SaralGyan.

They have a diwali offer, I am planning to subscribe. If anyone know about their services, please openly share feedback on their services.

Many thanks.
Click to expand...

Are you subscribed to their services, if yes, how has been the experience

Partha Boruah · Dec 31, 2017

Sonia said: ↑

Dear All,

Please share your experience if you have subscribed to any services of SaralGyan.

They have a diwali offer, I am planning to subscribe. If anyone know about their services, please openly share feedback on their services.

Many thanks.
Click to expand...

Madam, can we share saralgyan recommendation s. If yes, mail me at boruah04@gmail.com

Log in

Saral Gyan stock advisory

Shibi New Member

Shrikant bapat New Member

Manish Kumar New Member

sachin123 New Member

sachin123 New Member

Vijaykh New Member

Partha Boruah New Member

Reviews on SaralGyan advisory firm

Saral Gyan Hidden Gem

Log in

Saral Gyan stock advisory

Shibi New Member

Shrikant bapat New Member

Manish Kumar New Member

sachin123 New Member

sachin123 New Member

Vijaykh New Member

Partha Boruah New Member

Reviews on SaralGyan advisory firm

Saral Gyan Hidden Gem

Useful Searches