At one time in the not-so-distant past, Basant Maheshwari had the welfare of novice investors like you and me paramount in his heart. Basant would periodically hand-pick select top-quality stocks and hand them over on a platter to us.
This salutary exercise on Basant’s part helped us to latch on to winning stocks and we could effortlessly make ends meet.
To this day, we are beholden to Basant for giving us stocks like HDFC Bank, Page Industries, Gruh Finance, Repco Home Finance, Granules India etc. These stocks have contributed to the well-being of our portfolio.
Unfortunately, the slug fest over the Hawkins Cookers fiasco hurt Basant’s feelings to such an extent that he now views all novice investors as ingrates and has taken a vow never to make stock recommendations in public.
@safety2304 sorry, can't comment on individual stocks.
— Basant Maheshwari (@BMTheEquityDesk) June 13, 2016
The result of this sorry state of affairs is that we are now left high and dry and have to fend for ourselves.
Thankfully, there is no need to despair because our state-of-the-art surveillance mechanism helps us to keep a tab on what stocks the savvy investors are buying.
Basant Maheshwari’s latest stock pick
According to the latest information received from reliable sources, Basant Maheshwari has now taken a fancy for Cupid Ltd, the manufacturer of male and female condoms.
As of 31st March 2016, Basant holds 1,10,920 shares of Cupid Ltd while Pooja Maheshwari holds 56,800 shares. The holding of the duo is collectively worth Rs. 4.61 crore at the CMP of Rs. 275.
The holding of Basant and Pooja Maheshwari in Cupid Ltd as of date is not known. It is reasonable to assume that the holding would have remained unchanged since Basant prides himself on his long-term holding strategy and loathes the hop-in and hop-out strategy followed by traders.
Already a Mega Multibagger
Cupid Ltd enjoys the unique distinction of being a mega multibagger stock already. Over the past 24 months, the stock has given a mind-boggling return of 1264%.
However, thankfully, it is still a micro-cap with a market capitalisation of only Rs. 300 crore which implies that it has a long way to go.
Cupid discovered by anonymous blogger
Credit for discovering the potential of Cupid Ltd has to go to an anonymous blogger called aceinvestortrader. In a post of September 2014, when the micro-cap was available at a throwaway valuation of a few rupees, the blogger exhorted his followers to buy Cupid Ltd on the basis that it has “superb valuations for investment”. The blogger emphasized that Cupid Ltd is a “debt-free pharma company trading at a trailing PE of just 8 (and a forward PE of just 3) backed by ethical management (so rare in small caps) in a huge addressable market with hardly any competition”. It was also emphasized that Omprakash Garg, the Chairman of Cupid Ltd, had chosen not to draw any salary for the last few years.
Since that day, Cupid Ltd is up an eye-popping 1145%.
Repeat of Prima Plastics
It is worth recalling that the same blogger had also recommended a buy of Prima Plastics when it was still an unknown entity. Prima Plastics has also given super multibagger gains since then.
Red flags were a false alarm
Curiously, aceinvestortrader lost his nerve just a few months after his recommendation to buy Cupid Ltd. In December 2014, he advised his followers to “book profits” on the basis that there are a “lot of red flags here”.
Fortunately, the “red flags” turned out to be a false alarm. The concerns were misplaced. Cupid Ltd has stayed on the path that it was envisaged to travel on and went on to deliver the multibagger gains referred to earlier.
Controversy over suspension of trading by BSE
Investors in Cupid received a nasty shock when the BSE suddenly suspended trading in the stock due to alleged violations of guidelines relating to allotment of warrants. Fortunately, the issue was resolved soon. Om Garg maintained that the warrants were issued in a legal manner and that no SEBI or BSE regulations were violated.
CUPID LTD – KEY FUNDAMENTALS | |||
PARAMETER | VALUES | ||
MARKET CAP | (Rs CR) | 307 | |
EPS – TTM | (Rs) | [*S] | 15.06 |
P/E RATIO | (X) | [*S] | 18.33 |
FACE VALUE | (Rs) | 10 | |
LATEST DIVIDEND | (%) | 10.00 | |
LATEST DIVIDEND DATE | 08 AUG 2016 | ||
DIVIDEND YIELD | (%) | 1.09 | |
BOOK VALUE / SHARE | (Rs) | [*S] | 32.49 |
P/B RATIO | (Rs) | [*S] | 8.50 |
[*C] Consolidated [*S] Standalone
CUPID LTD – FINANCIAL RESULTS | |||
PARTICULARS (Rs CR) | JUN 2016 | JUN 2015 | % CHG |
NET SALES | 16.24 | 12.78 | 27.07 |
OTHER INCOME | – | ||
TOTAL INCOME | 16.24 | 12.78 | 27.07 |
TOTAL EXPENSES | 9.73 | 7.86 | 23.79 |
OPERATING PROFIT | 6.51 | 4.92 | 32.32 |
NET PROFIT | 3.83 | 3.02 | 26.82 |
EQUITY CAPITAL | 11.12 | 11.12 | – |
(Source: Business Standard)
Cupid fits into Basant’s template for finding multibagger stocks
Now, the all-important question is as to what it is about Cupid Ltd that has appealed to Basant Maheshwari.
The answer is that Cupid Ltd ticks all the boxes that Basant has outlined in the template for finding winning stocks in his bestseller “The Thoughtful Investor”.
It is this template that helped Basant identify winning stocks like HDFC Bank, Gruh Finance, Page Industries, Hawkins Cookers, Repco Home Finance when they were still in their infancy.
(i) High RoE:
This is a non-negotiable criterion. Basant has made it clear in “The Thoughtful Investor” that there is no point in backing stocks that are eking out a living themselves and barely making ends meet. Instead, we have to back stocks which are raking in mega bucks because the stock price is a function of the earnings.
Cupid Ltd boasts of a Return of Equity (RoE) of 36% and a Return on Investment (RoI) of 48% which is hefty by any standards.
(ii) Debt-Free/ low debt:
This is another non-negotiable criterion for finding winning stocks. Companies which are groaning under heavy debt are rarely able to lift themselves out of poverty.
Cupid Ltd is debt-free.
(iii) Insatiable demand for the product and huge scale of demand:
It is elementary that if a stock has to transition from a micro-cap to a mega-cap, the scale of opportunity must be infinite and there must be an insatiable demand for the product.
One’s imagination boggles at the size of the present and future demand for condoms and contraceptives in a Country like India with a vast population of young people.
In addition to India, there is an infinite demand from Countries in Africa which are grappling with problems of HIV and Aids.
(iv) Monopoly product:
Another elementary factor is that a product with great demand is bound to have competitors barging in to grab the loot. Here, the surprising revelation is that Cupid Ltd is stated to be the only manufacturer of “female condoms” in the Country. It is also stated to be the second manufacturer of condoms to have been pre-qualified by the WHO/ UNFPA (United Nations Population Fund) for worldwide public distribution.
(v) Valuations:
Basant is not a stickler for valuations. Basant is happy to pay a high price for the stock if he is assured that he is buying a quality company with predictable earnings. In fact, all of Basant’s stock picks like HDFC Bank, Page Industries, Hawkins Cookers etc are quoting at stiff valuations.
At the CMP of Rs. 274, Cupid Ltd is quoting at a P/E of 18x TTM EPS. This valuation may be high or low depending on one’s perspective. Basant’s perspective may be that given Cupid’s high RoE, debt-free status, scope for growth etc, the price is not unreasonable.
(vi) Dividend yield:
Another factor that requires to be borne in mind is that Cupid offers a dividend yield of 1.09%. This offers downside protection because if the price slumps, the dividend yield will increase and dividend hunters will move to buy the stock, thereby arresting a downward slide in the price.
Forbes Asia’s Best Under a Billion
Anu Raghunathan of Forbes has confirmed that Cupid Ltd has been awarded the prestigious title of “Forbes Asia’s Best Under a Billion” title. This title has been conferred on the basis that global condom sales are growing at a CAGR of 9% and are projected to hit 38.2 billion pieces by 2019. If Cupid manages to snare even a tiny fraction of the global market, it will effortlessly become a mega-cap.
Investors’ Presentation
To our good fortune, Cupid Ltd has provided an easy-to-understand investors’ presentation where all the core data about the Company together with the investment rationale is readily available:
Core facts:
(i) India’s Leading manufacturer of male and female condoms
(ii) Capacity of ~350 mn male (325mn) & female (25mn) condoms
(iii) In-house research and development centre
(iv) 18+ years of Industry experience
(v) Presence in 26+ countries
(vi) ~75% revenues from Direct exports
(vii) 1st Indian company to get WHO/UNFP prequalification for female condoms
(viii) Employs 100+ people with average experience of 10 years
(ix) Robust expansion plans and strong order book
(x) Debt Free balance Sheet
(xi) Low Equity Base
(xii) Long Term agreements with WHO/UNFPA
Investment Rationale
Strong Balance Sheet
Debt free and low equity base, potential to grow by multiple folds
Business Model
State of the art infrastructure with world class products and basket of new value added products
Competitive Advantage
Low cost of production considering global peers
Experience
Experienced management and production team
Initiating Coverage Research Report by BOB Capital
Akanksha Tripathi and Rishabh Mehta of BOB Capital have issued a detailed initiating coverage research report in which a professional analysis of the prospects of Cupid Ltd has been conducted. The duo has recommended a buy on the basis that lifestyle changes, huge potential target segment & quality product will drive Cupid’s revenue/earnings by ~44%/52% CAGR over FY15-18e. The duo has predicted a price target of Rs. 327 which implies an upside of about 20% (68% from the time the report was issued).
Conclusion
So, it does appear that Basant Maheshwari has got himself yet another winning stock which will sparkle in his portfolio as it turns into yet another multibagger!
You should not assume he may still be holding same stock even today. Some old timers tell me now his picks/sector bullishness changes faster than you can imagine. From Consumers to Home Finance to B2B Pharma to Internet of things and now MFIs. In recent ET Now interview he said only MFIs can grow above normal growth rates. We will see for how long he remains bullish on them.
Please mention the person who first bought Cupid in size but sold because of red flags. Check out Madras Parameswaran Manoj Mahadev(bulk buy on Cupid)
Aceinvestortrader is a blogger and not a big buyer. He continues to track Cupid and his last update on the script was on July 13, 2016.
I am aware of Aceinvestor. All I am pointing out is that I picked up almost 3.25% & sold when I could not reconcile with some items.Check out 24 Dec 2014 bulk buys on Cupid
Deal Date
Client Name
Deal Type
Quantity
Price
11 Jun 2015 PARAM CAPITAL S 64290 67.64
19 May 2015 MADRAS PARAMESWARAN MANOJ MAHADEV S 142089 90.50
24 Dec 2014 PRABHA GUPTA S 56812 49.75
24 Dec 2014 PRABHA GUPTA P 56812 49.14
24 Dec 2014 MADRAS PARAMESWARAN MANOJ MAHADEV P 126000 51.79
Can you elaborate further ?
I had spoken to Om Garg and inquired about Greenmate corporation (they had 27% percent shareholding which no longer exists) & their technology transfer-did not get a satisfactory answer. I inquired as to why stock markets are not getting updates on orders as and when they are awarded-the answer just raised more questions. Also Female Health (US company-read their conference calls) was a leader in this field (female condoms)& when they won the Brazil contract for WHO , I inquired as to what happened & what were future prospects-did not get an answer that appealed to me. At one point I felt that they had a great product -Female condom(unique but names like Hindustan Lever /TTK etc. were working on new patents concerning the product) & management did not seem to have a 3-5 year in place if competition picked up in whats technically a commoditised space. Also management was just keen on WHO & had no plans to grow domestically. Strangely I did a lot of walkaround in major metros -speaking to chemists & checking if they stocked female condoms or Cupid products.
I have to admit that I got the market move wrong by a mile but I would rather step away than get swept away later.
Zika virus story will however support them as in Brazil-FC2 is a big hit. Also I had other queries on receivables etc.
Its SCRIP not script. A script is a hand written text
Cupid Ltd has given 4-5x returns in 2015 and post that it has now corrected. It is a small cap company operates in rubber space and manufactures different types of condoms. In year 2012, the company recorded sales of INR 25 Cr which has increased to INR 61 Cr in 2016. Net profits in 2012, were INR 0.59 Cr which has increased to INR 16 Cr in FY2016. The company is consistently and steadily making progress in their business. Down the line also more than 10% CAGR they will be able to maintain and possibly with some more improvement in margins they will grow PAT by 15% or more CAGR for next few years. But since the stock is yet very small investors with good risk appetite can buy 2-3% of their portfolio in such stock on any declines from current levels of 280 and hold for next 2-3 years.
Honestly not very positive on Cupid though it do have some upside left, it is for now very expensive on fundamental levels.
I agree Female Health with a better product is available at mcap of USD 38 mio & hopefully with their meRger with Aspen-they can go places.Cupid in comparison is quite expensive (not sure sour grapes 🙂 theory)
regards
Will Cupid can still deliver multibagger returns ?
Seems it will have a consolidation period for next year.
Cupid annual report is out.Basant Maheswari holding 1% of equity in Cupid.Also noticed another name with Maheswari (Pooja Maheswari) holding 0.5%.
https://2609a80b58a32337a933e6cc6c1805d43b145842.googledrive.com/host/0B8z2fpVljRiUfkJWd0pnWHNKdEFuRVhkM0xtd21rcGdoUUlWbTdXNnh6dDRIcHkwblZ6Unc/annual_report.pdf
Cupid Annual Report can be found here::
https://2609a80b58a32337a933e6cc6c1805d43b145842.googledrive.com/host/0B8z2fpVljRiUfkJWd0pnWHNKdEFuRVhkM0xtd21rcGdoUUlWbTdXNnh6dDRIcHkwblZ6Unc/annual_report.pdf
thanks for the reply , manoj mahadev.
appreciate your sincerety.