METHODOLOGY FOR INDIA
*based on results from calendar year 2013
StarMine objectively measures the performance of analysts based on the returns of their buy/sell recommendations and the accuracy of their earnings estimates. The 2014 awards for India are based on the performance during calendar year 2013 of recommendations and estimates on companies that are based in India. Only analyst performance on companies that are based in India is included in the awards calculations.
Top Earnings Estimator: Banks
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Mehta, Tejas |
HSBC Global Research |
|
2 |
Sethia, Arun |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
|
3 |
Upadhya, Shashin |
ICICI Securities |
Top Stock Pickers: Banks
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Mehta, Tejas |
HSBC Global Research |
|
2 |
Jayaraman, Ganeshram |
Spark Capital |
|
3 |
Agarwal, Anil |
Morgan Stanley |
Top Earnings Estimator: Construction & Materials
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Maniar, Krupal |
ICICI Securities |
|
2 |
Purswani, Deepak |
ICICI Direct |
|
3 |
Shah, Rupa |
Prabhudas Lilladher |
Top Stock Pickers: Construction & Materials
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Mahawar, Manish |
Edelweiss Securities |
|
2 |
Akella, Abhijit |
IIFL |
|
3 |
Cirumalla, Ranjit |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
Top Earnings Estimator: Consumer Goods & Services
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Singh, Rahul |
Karvy Stockbroking |
|
2 |
Shah, Rashesh |
ICICI Direct |
|
3 |
Modi, Mohit |
CRISIL |
Top Stock Pickers: Consumer Goods & Services
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Memani, Suman |
Anand Rathi |
|
2 |
Nagaraju, A. |
First Call India |
|
3 |
Chhoda, Bharat |
ICICI Direct |
Top Earnings Estimator: Diversified Financials
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Sheth, Vishal |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
|
2 |
Kunal, Shah |
Edelweiss Securities |
|
3 |
Uberoi, Karan |
JM Financial |
Top Stock Pickers: Diversified Financials
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Kushwaha, Ashish |
First Call India |
|
2 |
Sheth, Vishal |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
|
3 |
Uberoi, Karan |
JM Financial |
Top Earnings Estimator: Diversified Industrials
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Baid, Renu |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
|
2 |
Garg, Lokesh |
Kotak Securities |
|
3 |
Ganti, Lakshminarayana * |
Standard Chartered Bank |
- * Currently inactive
Top Stock Pickers: Diversified Industrials
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Korde, Rohan |
Anand Rathi |
|
2 |
Nagaraju, A. |
First Call India |
|
3 |
Agarwal, Satyam |
Motilal Oswal Securities |
Top Earnings Estimator: Energy
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Lakhotia, Tarun |
Kotak Securities |
|
2 |
Ginde, Vidyadhar |
BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research |
|
3 |
Banerjee, Nilesh |
Goldman Sachs |
Top Stock Pickers: Energy
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Patel, Mayur * |
Spark Capital |
|
2 |
Modani, Ballabh |
Religare Capital Markets |
|
3 |
Mookim, Sanjay |
Credit Suisse |
- * Currently inactive
Top Earnings Estimator: Food, Household & Personal Products
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Maheshwari, Vivek |
CLSA |
|
2 |
Kakkad, Gaurang |
Religare Capital Markets |
|
3 |
Chheda, Pritesh |
Emkay |
Top Stock Pickers: Food, Household & Personal Products
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Lohchab, Varun * |
Religare Capital Markets |
|
2 |
Panthaki, Percy |
IIFL |
|
3 |
Patel, Hemant |
Axis Capital |
- * Now at CIMB Research
Top Earnings Estimator: Information Technology
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Taneja, Manik |
Emkay |
|
2 |
Dugar, Rumit |
Religare Capital Markets |
|
3 |
Agarwal, Vishal |
Jefferies |
Top Stock Pickers: Information Technology
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Banerjee, Basudeb |
Quant Broking |
|
2 |
Koul, Kuldeep |
ICICI Securities |
|
3 |
Shah, Hardik |
KR Choksey |
Top Earnings Estimator: Media
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Nangalia, Swati; Vora, Nikhil * |
IDFC Securities |
|
2 |
Lal, Mohan |
Elara Securities |
|
3 |
Negandhi, Chirag |
Axis Capital |
- * No longer with firm
Top Stock Pickers: Media
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Nangalia, Swati; Vora, Nikhil * |
IDFC Securities |
|
2 |
Mittal, Karan |
ICICI Direct |
|
3 |
Negandhi, Chirag |
Axis Capital |
- * No longer with firm
Top Earnings Estimator: Metals & Mining
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Mishra, Neelkanth |
Credit Suisse |
|
2 |
Shah, Bijal |
IIFL |
|
3 |
Basu, Bhaskar |
BofA Merrill Lynch Global Research |
Top Stock Pickers: Metals & Mining
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Bansal, Sandip |
UBS |
|
2 |
Parekh, Pinakin |
J.P. Morgan |
|
3 |
Sanghvi, Jimesh |
Avendus Securities |
Top Earnings Estimator: Pharmaceuticals
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Singhal, Abhishek |
Macquarie Research |
|
2 |
Nair, Prashant |
Citi Investment Research & Analysis |
|
3 |
Talati, Chirag |
Espirito Santo Investment Bank |
Top Stock Pickers: Pharmaceuticals
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Kohli, Daljeet |
IndiaNivesh Securities |
|
2 |
Kour Nangra, Sarabjit |
Angel Broking |
|
3 |
Baisiwala, Sameer |
Morgan Stanley |
Top Earnings Estimator: Real Estate
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Singh, Hansraj * |
IDBI Capital Market Services |
|
2 |
Pal, Sandipan |
Motilal Oswal Securities |
|
3 |
Nandurkar, Mahesh |
CLSA |
- * Currently inactive
Top Stock Pickers: Real Estate
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Pathak, Gaurav |
Standard Chartered Bank |
|
2 |
Jagnani, Ashish |
UBS |
|
3 |
Maheshwari, Himanshu |
JM Financial |
Top Earnings Estimator: Transportation
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Gandhi, Jinesh |
Motilal Oswal Securities |
|
2 |
Jayaraj, Annamalai |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
|
3 |
Chellappa, Govindarajan; Kakulavarapu, Rajasa |
Jefferies |
Top Stock Pickers: Transportation
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Sharma, Pooja; Lal, Mohan |
Elara Securities |
|
2 |
Gupta, Sonal |
UBS |
|
3 |
Kothari, Yaresh |
Angel Broking |
Top Earnings Estimator: Utilities
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Sharma, Pankaj |
UBS |
|
2 |
Shah, Amish |
Credit Suisse |
|
3 |
Biraia, Vishal |
Batlivala & Karani Securities |
Top Stock Pickers: Utilities
|
Rank |
Analyst |
Firm |
|
1 |
Anand, Abhineet |
Quant Broking |
|
2 |
Goel, Prakash Gaurav |
ICICI Securities |
|
3 |
Bhatia, Inderjeetsingh |
Macquarie Research |
Thats great but what about their Stock picks ?
Yes, I keep watching this site for some time, This always posts news and / or research reports few trading sessions late. By that time, market technicals would have changed. I see lot of stock picks by Market analysts which were disclosed by this site only when they gain 100% or 150% returns since their investment.
This is what even I had pointed out few days ago. The website should dedicate a column for who recommended what today or yesterday and which big investor bought which stock and price. Like yesterday, RJ bought 2% stake in MCX at 560 per share total amounting to 55 cr approx.
Correction. He bought 10
Lacs share of mcx at 660 total amounting to 66 crores.
Looks like every brokerage house has been awarded one or other award so that everyone’s happy.